Back to Insights
Grid & Policy10 min read

North Carolina Made Data Centers Pay for the Plug. Who Pays for the Power Plants?

Duke Energy's first large-load tariff makes data centers pay for their grid connections. North Carolina's governor and attorney general want them to help pay for new power plants too. Here's what's in the deal, what's missing, and how it compares with Ohio.

Data center campus and a natural gas power plant under construction in the rolling hills of North Carolina at sunset, beside an old tobacco barn.

Key takeaways

  • Duke Energy has proposed North Carolina's first large-load tariff, which requires data centers to prepay for dedicated grid equipment, pay a 75% minimum bill and sign 10- to 15-year contracts.
  • Amazon, Google, Microsoft, a Meta affiliate, the Department of Defense and the state's Public Staff support the deal.
  • Governor Josh Stein and Attorney General Jeff Jackson say it leaves out the biggest cost: the new power plants data center growth requires.
  • Duke expects data centers and other large users to drive more than 80% of its new demand, and its resource plan calls for about 9.7 GW of new gas-fired capacity by 2033.
  • A decision from the North Carolina Utilities Commission is expected in mid-November.

Last week I wrote about Ohio, where data center anger is boiling over at the local level while the real decisions about who pays are made inside a regional power market most voters never think about.

North Carolina is having the same argument, but it's further along. The state now has a concrete proposal on the table that spells out what data centers will pay. The fight has moved from "should data centers pay their way?" to a sharper question: pay for what, exactly?

In October, Duke Energy proposed North Carolina's first large-load tariff, a special set of rules for data centers and other very large electricity customers. Attorney General Jeff Jackson called it "a massive step forward in making sure data centers pay their fair share," according to WFDD. Then he added: "We're not done yet."

As NC Newsline reported, Governor Josh Stein and Jackson are now calling on data center owners to help pay for something the deal doesn't cover: new power plants.

That distinction, between paying for the plug and paying for the plant, is the most important idea in data center energy policy right now. It's also the one most people miss.

What Duke actually proposed

According to the North Carolina Department of Justice, the proposed tariff would apply to customers whose contracts are signed on or after June 1, 2026, and who either use 50 MW or more at an average load factor of 80% or higher, or use 150 MW or more at any load factor.

The main terms:

  • Upfront payment for dedicated equipment. Large users must pay cash up front, within 60 days of signing their first contract, for grid equipment built only for them, such as new substations.
  • A 75% minimum bill. Customers pay for at least 75% of the capacity they signed up for each month, even if they use less.
  • Long contracts. Terms run 10 to 15 years.
  • Exit protections. Customers must give two to four years' notice before leaving, keep paying during that period, and post cash or financial guarantees to cover early-exit penalties.
  • Curtailment. In their first years of service, large users must cut power use when Duke asks during periods of grid strain.
  • Transparency. Duke must get approval for a public contract template, so data center contract terms would be public for the first time.

The deal has unusually broad support. Duke's settlement partners include the state's Public Staff, Amazon, Google, Microsoft, Andale LLC (a Meta affiliate), the U.S. Department of Defense and other federal agencies.

From where I sit, after years on the financing side of energy, these are real protections. Upfront payment for dedicated equipment means a canceled project doesn't leave households holding the bill for a substation nobody uses. A minimum bill plus long contracts and exit fees turns a speculative load request into something close to a committed revenue stream. That's exactly the kind of structure lenders and regulators want to see.

The gap: wires vs. power plants

Here's what the tariff doesn't do.

It makes large customers pay for the grid equipment that connects them: the substations, lines and upgrades built to serve their sites. It does not make them pay directly for the new power plants their demand requires.

That matters because Duke projects that more than 80% of its new demand will come from data centers and other large users, according to the Department of Justice. Duke is planning new generation and transmission to meet that demand. Under the current proposal, the cost of that new generation would flow into rates the normal way, shared across every customer class, including households and small businesses.

Jackson's office raised three specific gaps:

  • Generation costs. Large users should pay for the new generation they cause, not just their connection.
  • A separate rate class. Without one, it's hard to measure the true cost of serving data centers and make sure they pay it.
  • Clean energy. Duke announced a clean energy tariff in 2024 but hasn't filed it. Jackson wants a "build or bring your own" clean energy option.

Governor Stein put it simply. The proposal, he said, sets a new floor, but there's more work to do. He wants the Utilities Commission to require data centers to pay the full cost of their impact, including generation, and bring their own clean energy.

Why generation is the expensive part

Connection costs are real, but they're usually the smaller piece. The big money is in power plants.

Duke's 2025 Carolinas Resource Plan, reported by POWER Magazine, projects customer energy needs over the next 15 years growing at eight times the rate of the prior 15 years. To meet it, Duke plans about 9.7 GW of new gas-fired capacity by 2033, about 7.9 GW of battery storage, at least 7.9 GW of solar, and more than 1.1 GW of new nuclear by 2037. It also proposes keeping some coal plants running two to four years longer than planned.

Data centers are a big reason the forecast keeps rising. According to Canary Media, Duke's projected capacity need for large loads grew from about 3.9 GW in early 2024 to almost 6 GW by May 2025. Major projects include Amazon Web Services' $10 billion campus in Richmond County, the largest single capital project in state history, along with Microsoft and Apple in Catawba County and Google in Caldwell County.

Governor Stein's office cites even larger numbers. The governor's bipartisan Energy Policy Task Force projects that electricity rates could rise as much as 70% over 15 years. A report by Energy Futures Group found that large loads, mostly data centers, would cost ratepayers $50 billion over the next 25 years and account for 85% of new demand through 2035 under business as usual.

The same report found something more hopeful: if half of new large customers brought or paid for their own committed clean generation and operated flexibly, other ratepayers would save about $20 billion.

That's the core of the fight. A tariff that covers connections protects customers from stranded substations. A tariff that also covers generation protects them from the much bigger cost of the power plants themselves.

Why households are paying attention

This isn't happening in a vacuum. North Carolina customers are already facing rate increases.

According to the Department of Justice, the proposed Duke Energy Carolinas settlement would still raise residential bills about 9.5% on average, and Jackson refused to sign on. Duke Energy Progress is seeking a residential increase of about 15%, which Jackson says includes nearly $960 million in unnecessary hikes over two years.

When bills are already climbing, the question of who pays for the next generation of power plants stops being abstract. Every gigawatt of new capacity that ends up in general rates is a cost shared by families who will never use a data center's output directly.

How North Carolina compares with Ohio

North Carolina's proposal looks a lot like the AEP Ohio data center tariff that Ohio regulators approved in 2025, but there are some key differences.

TermAEP Ohio (approved 2025)Duke Energy NC (proposed 2026)
Who it coversNew data centers above 25 MW50 MW+ at 80%+ load factor, or 150 MW+
Minimum bill85% of contracted capacity75% of contracted capacity
Contract lengthUp to 12 years, with a 4-year ramp10 to 15 years
Upfront paymentFinancial assurances requiredCash upfront for dedicated equipment within 60 days
Exit termsExit fees if canceled2 to 4 years' notice, plus penalties and collateral
CurtailmentNot a core termRequired in early years during grid strain
Pays for new generation?NoNo, which is the open fight

Neither tariff makes data centers directly fund new power plants. That's why North Carolina's push matters beyond its borders. If the Utilities Commission, or later the legislature, adds a generation requirement, it would set a new national benchmark.

What "bring your own clean energy" means

Stein and Jackson both want a path for data centers to bring their own clean energy, an idea that also shows up in the voluntary federal Ratepayer Protection Pledge Duke joined in July 2026. As WRAL reported, that pledge asks large users to "build, bring or buy" new power supplies and pay for necessary grid upgrades. Stein and Jackson want those commitments made legally binding.

In practice, "bring your own" can take several forms:

  • Signing long-term power purchase agreements for new solar, wind or nuclear capacity on the same grid.
  • Co-locating dedicated generation or battery storage at the campus.
  • Paying for specific new resources through a clean transition tariff.
  • Committing to flexible operation, cutting load during peaks so the grid needs less new capacity.

The appeal is simple. If a data center brings its own new supply, it adds generation instead of competing with households for existing generation. It also gives the company a predictable, often cleaner, power cost over the life of the contract. The levelized cost of a new solar-plus-storage project can be locked in for 15 to 20 years, which is something gas price exposure can't offer.

The other side of the argument

To be fair, Duke and its settlement partners argue the tariff already protects existing customers while letting North Carolina compete for investment. The fact that Amazon, Google, Microsoft and a Meta affiliate signed on is significant. It means the largest buyers accept minimum bills, upfront payments and curtailment, terms that would have been unthinkable a few years ago.

There are real reasons for caution about going further. Generation costs are harder to assign than a substation. A power plant serves the whole system, not one customer. A large, steady load can also help spread a utility's fixed costs over more kilowatt-hours and, in the right conditions, put downward pressure on average rates. And data center campuses bring construction jobs and property tax revenue to rural counties that badly need both.

Some communities are pushing back anyway. Tarboro's town council rejected a proposed $6.4 billion data center, and opposition has grown to a proposed campus in Apex. The economic case for data centers is real, but so is the political cost when residents believe they're paying for someone else's growth.

What to watch next

According to NC Political News, Duke expects a decision from the North Carolina Utilities Commission in mid-November. Key questions:

  • Does the Commission approve the settlement as filed, or add conditions on generation costs?
  • Does Duke file the clean energy tariff it announced in 2024?
  • Does the Commission create a separate rate class for large loads?
  • Do Duke's voluntary federal pledge commitments become legally binding?
  • How do the Duke Energy Carolinas and Duke Energy Progress rate cases land for residential customers?

What this means for developers and lenders

If you're developing or financing data center capacity in the Southeast, North Carolina's direction is clear even before the final order.

Expect to prepay for dedicated grid equipment. Expect minimum bills, long terms and real exit costs. And expect pressure, probably growing, to show where your power is coming from, not just how you connect to the grid. This is the core question I explored in Who Should Pay for the AI Power Boom.

The projects that move fastest will be the ones that show up with their own answer to the generation question: a PPA for new capacity, on-site battery storage, a flexible load profile, or all three. That's not just good politics. It reduces the regulatory risk lenders price into every deal.

Before committing to a site, run the full power cost and total cost of ownership under a few scenarios: today's tariff, a tariff that adds a generation charge, and a bring-your-own-power structure. The difference between them is the real price of the site.

The bottom line

North Carolina has already won the first round. Data centers will pay for their own connections, sign long contracts and carry real exit risk. That's a meaningful change, and it happened with the biggest tech companies at the table.

The second round is harder and more expensive. It's about the power plants, and whether the companies driving more than 80% of new demand help pay for the generation it takes to serve them. Whatever the Utilities Commission decides this month, that question isn't going away in North Carolina, in Ohio, or anywhere else the data center boom is landing.

Chris Kalowes

Founder, WattThe?!

Energy intelligence. Simplified.

Frequently asked questions

What is a large-load tariff?+

A large-load tariff is a special set of utility rules for very large customers like data centers. It typically requires minimum monthly bills, long contracts, upfront payments for dedicated equipment and exit fees, so other customers aren't left paying for infrastructure if a project is canceled or uses less power than promised.

What does Duke Energy's proposed North Carolina tariff require?+

It covers customers with contracts signed on or after June 1, 2026, that use 50 MW or more at an 80% or higher load factor, or 150 MW or more. They must prepay for dedicated grid equipment, pay at least 75% of their contracted capacity each month, sign 10- to 15-year contracts, give two to four years' notice to exit, and curtail use during grid strain in their early years.

Why do Governor Stein and Attorney General Jackson say it isn't enough?+

The tariff covers the cost of connecting data centers to the grid, but not the cost of new power plants their demand requires. Duke projects more than 80% of its new demand will come from large users, so Stein and Jackson want data centers to pay for new generation, a separate rate class, and a clean energy option.

How does North Carolina's proposal compare with Ohio's?+

AEP Ohio's approved tariff covers new data centers above 25 MW with an 85% minimum bill and contracts up to 12 years. Duke's North Carolina proposal has a 75% minimum bill, 10- to 15-year contracts, cash upfront for dedicated equipment and curtailment requirements. Neither makes data centers directly pay for new generation.

When will North Carolina decide?+

Duke expects a decision from the North Carolina Utilities Commission in mid-November 2026.