Back to Insights
Grid & Policy10 min read

Ohio's Data Center Revolt Is Real. Why Isn't It Moving Statewide Votes?

Ohio electricity costs about 50% more than six years ago and data centers are a local flashpoint. Here's why the anger isn't moving statewide votes, where power bills are actually set, and what every data center state should learn.

Data center campus rising beside an Ohio cornfield and red barn at sunset, with transmission lines and a VOTE yard sign.

Key takeaways

  • Ohio electricity costs about 50% more than it did six years ago, and residential bills rose 13.5% year over year this October.
  • More than a dozen Ohio communities will vote on local data center limits this November, yet only 3% of likely voters call data centers and AI their top issue.
  • Much of an Ohio power bill is set by PJM, a regional market where data center demand has pushed capacity prices to record highs.
  • Bills lag the decisions behind them, so even fast policy changes won't show up for voters before the next election.
  • The real decisions on who pays sit with PUCO, the statehouse and PJM, not the county zoning board.

Drive through central Ohio and you can see the change from the road. Where corn and soybeans grew a few years ago, huge gray warehouses full of servers now light up the night sky. They sit behind chain-link fences, wrapped in rows of rooftop cooling units and fed by new high-voltage lines.

The Columbus area has become one of the fastest-growing data center markets in the country. According to The New York Times, Ohio's data center footprint has grown roughly ninefold since 2020. Meta, Google, Amazon and Microsoft have all built or announced major campuses in the region, drawn by available land, fiber, tax incentives and, until recently, plentiful power.

Ohio families can see the change in their power bills too. The Times reports that electricity in Ohio costs about 50% more than it did six years ago. Public Utilities Commission of Ohio data shows residential electric bills up 13.5% on average year over year this October. Some cities, including Cleveland and Mansfield, saw increases close to or above 20%. Natural gas bills rose too, by 4.8% statewide.

Put those together and you would expect an election shaped by power bills and data centers. At the local level, that's happening. More than a dozen Ohio communities will vote this November on measures to restrict data centers. Residents are packing township meetings, going door to door for petition signatures, and testifying for hours against proposed campuses on family farmland.

At the state level, it mostly isn't. In a recent New York Times/Siena poll, only 3% of likely Ohio voters named data centers and AI as the most important issue in their vote for Congress. Cost of living and foreign policy ranked far ahead of it.

One University of Cincinnati political scientist summed it up for the Times: local communities are "in full-on revolt over data centers," but that anger "hasn't necessarily translated one to one to the rest of state politics."

From where I sit, after 15+ years on the financing and deal side of energy, that gap isn't surprising. It comes down to how power bills are actually built, who decides each piece, and how long each decision takes to reach a household.

The anger is local. The costs are not.

When residents fight a data center, they fight what they can see: the warehouse on the farm down the road, the hum of cooling fans, the water use, the new substation, the truck traffic during construction. That's a reasonable fight, and local governments do have real authority over zoning, land use and permitting.

Much of what shows up on an Ohio power bill, though, isn't decided at the county zoning board. A typical Ohio electric bill has three main parts:

  • Generation: the cost of the electricity you use, plus the cost of keeping enough power plants available to meet peak demand (capacity).
  • Transmission: the cost of the high-voltage network, the tall steel lattice towers that move bulk power across the region.
  • Distribution: the local "last-mile" network of poles, wires and transformers that delivers power to your home.

Ohio is part of PJM, the regional grid operator and wholesale electricity market that covers all or part of 13 states plus Washington, D.C. PJM runs the capacity auctions that pay power plants to be available during peak demand, and it plans much of the regional transmission system. Those costs are shared across the whole footprint and flow into retail bills.

As one principal at the Brattle Group told The New York Times, "You could have data centers in Virginia increasing costs for customers in Ohio."

That's the disconnect. A township can block the data center down the road and still see its bill rise, because the cost arrives through a regional market most voters have never heard of.

Who decidesWhat they controlHow fast it reaches your bill
Township / countyZoning, land use, local permitsIndirect; doesn't set rates
Ohio legislatureUtility law, tax incentives, rate structuresMonths to years
PUCO (appointed by the governor)Utility rates, tariffs, cost allocationThrough rate cases, often years
PJMCapacity auctions, regional transmission planning1 to 3 years after each auction

What the data says about capacity costs

For years, PJM's capacity market was a sleepy corner of the power business. Prices were low because the region had plenty of supply. That changed fast as utilities across the footprint filed forecasts showing huge new loads, mostly from data centers.

PJM's capacity price for the 2025/26 delivery year jumped roughly tenfold from the year before, to about $270 per megawatt-day. The next two auctions both hit the newly imposed price cap. According to Utility Dive, the auction held in December 2025 for the 2027/28 delivery year cleared at $333.44 per MW-day, a record for the third straight auction, with a total cost of about $16.4 billion. PJM estimated that without the cap, the price would have been closer to $530 per MW-day.

Even at those prices, the auction came in roughly 6,600 MW short of PJM's reliability target. PJM said the growth in its demand forecast was almost entirely driven by data centers.

PJM's independent market monitor has put a number on it: data centers accounted for $29.4 billion in higher capacity costs across the past four capacity auctions. The monitor has also argued that new data centers should not be connected unless they can be reliably served.

Those auction results don't hit bills right away. Capacity is bought years ahead, and the costs show up when each delivery year begins. That's one reason Ohio households are only now feeling the full effect of auctions held in 2024 and 2025.

PJM has also told governors it is preparing a "reliability backstop" procurement to secure additional generation for data center growth. In a letter to Governor DeWine, the Ohio House Democratic Caucus warned that unless Ohio creates a separate rate class, all Ohioans could end up paying for that new generation.

Transmission: the cost nobody votes on

Transmission is the second layer, and in some ways the less visible one.

Ohio's Consumers' Counsel has said Ohio utilities passed about $16 billion in new transmission spending through to customers from 2017 to 2025. More than $10 billion of that went through PJM's "supplemental" project process, which gets far less regulatory review than regional reliability projects. Many of those projects are high-voltage lines and substations built to serve large new loads, including data centers.

Nationally, utilities are planning about $1.4 trillion in grid investments by 2030. Some of that is long overdue modernization. Some of it exists only because of the data center boom. Either way, once those assets go into the rate base, customers typically pay for them over 30 to 40 years.

That's the part that worries me most. Capacity prices can fall if new supply arrives. Transmission costs, once built in, are locked in for decades.

Why bills lag the decisions behind them

There's a timing problem too. Electricity prices lag. The bill you pay today reflects regulatory decisions made years ago, capacity auctions held one to three years earlier, and recent fuel prices.

Data centers move slowly as well. A large campus often takes several years to permit, finance, build and connect, and the grid upgrades behind it can take even longer. AEP Ohio paused new data center service agreements in central Ohio in March 2023 because the grid couldn't keep up, and it reported more than 30 GW of preliminary data center requests in its territory. For context, AEP projects about 5 GW of data center load in central Ohio by 2030.

So even if Ohio's next governor and legislature acted quickly, the results probably wouldn't show up on bills before the next election. Voters feel today's prices but are asked to judge policies whose effects arrive years later. It's hard for any candidate to run on a clear before-and-after when the "after" is three to five years away.

What Ohio has already done

It's worth noting that Ohio isn't starting from zero. Over the past two years, the state has taken several steps that other states are now studying.

AEP Ohio's data center tariff

In July 2025, PUCO approved a landmark AEP Ohio tariff for new data centers, reported in detail by POWER Magazine. Under it:

  • New data centers with loads above 25 MW must pay for at least 85% of their contracted capacity each month, whether or not they use it.
  • Contracts can run up to 12 years, including a four-year ramp-up period.
  • Customers must provide financial assurances and pay exit fees if they cancel.

The logic is simple. If a utility builds grid capacity for a customer that never shows up, or shows up at a fraction of its promised load, someone still pays for those wires. The tariff makes sure that someone is the data center developer, not the household down the road. Data center companies challenged the structure, and PUCO rejected their request to undo it.

House Bill 15

In 2025, Ohio lawmakers passed House Bill 15, which ended the "legacy generation rider" that had made ratepayers subsidize two aging Ohio Valley Electric Corp. coal plants, a charge dating back to the scandal-plagued House Bill 6 of 2019. The bill also requires utilities to file regular rate cases and justify how they spend customer money.

Neither step solves the regional capacity problem. But together they show that cost allocation, meaning who pays for what, is the lever states actually control.

Where the candidates stand

Both major candidates for governor have tied energy to affordability, and both have stopped short of fully embracing or fully opposing data centers.

According to the Ohio Capital Journal and other coverage, Democrat Amy Acton has backed a conditional moratorium on new data centers, with new sites required to use previously developed land, pay their own infrastructure costs, and drop nondisclosure agreements. She has also called for overhauling PUCO's membership and expanding bill-assistance programs.

Republican Vivek Ramaswamy has said he would emphasize brownfield sites, streamline permitting, and expand natural gas supply. He has also proposed free electricity for residents living near data centers, which he later said would cover only the generation portion of the bill. Experts have questioned how that plan would work legally.

In the U.S. Senate race, both Sherrod Brown and Senator Jon Husted have said communities should get to decide whether data centers are built.

The most important point for power bills gets the least attention: Ohio's next governor appoints all five members of the Public Utilities Commission of Ohio, the body that approves rates, tariffs like AEP's data center rule, and how grid costs are split between customer classes. That appointment power may matter more to future bills than any campaign promise about a single facility.

The other side of the ledger

To be fair, data centers aren't only a cost story.

Large campuses bring construction jobs, local property tax revenue, and investment in communities that have seen little of it in decades. When a big, steady load connects to a grid with spare capacity, it can spread fixed costs over more kilowatt-hours and help lower average rates. Some operators are also paying for their own generation, signing long-term power purchase agreements for new solar, wind, nuclear and gas, and adding battery storage that can support the grid during peaks.

The problem isn't data centers as such. It's speed and cost allocation. When demand grows faster than supply and the rules for who pays haven't caught up, households end up backstopping risk they never agreed to take on.

What every state with a data center pipeline should take from Ohio

Ohio is an early version of a debate coming to every state where large data center campuses are planned: Virginia, Texas, Georgia, Pennsylvania, Arizona, Indiana and more. A few lessons stand out.

  1. 1.Local control isn't cost control. Zoning decides where facilities go. It doesn't decide who pays for regional capacity and transmission. States that want to protect households need to act at the rate-design and market level, not just the county level.
  2. 2.Rate design is where the real fight is. Separate rate classes for very large loads, minimum-take contracts, upfront collateral and exit fees can keep the cost of serving data centers with the data centers. Ohio's AEP tariff is one model. This is the core question I explored in Who Should Pay for the AI Power Boom.
  3. 3.Scrutinize transmission, not just generation. Capacity prices make headlines, but transmission costs stay on bills for decades. Supplemental projects built for specific large customers deserve the same review as any other major rate-base investment.
  4. 4.Flexibility should be rewarded. Data centers that can cut load during grid emergencies, bring their own generation, or pair with battery storage put less strain on the system. That flexibility is worth real money, and rate design should pay for it. Bitcoin miners have shown for years that large loads can act as grid assets when the incentives line up.
  5. 5.Transparency builds trust. Communities push back hardest when deals are negotiated behind nondisclosure agreements and costs show up later. Much of the industry's public trust problem is really a disclosure problem.
  6. 6.Supply has to keep pace. The AI power wall is real. If new generation and transmission can't be built as fast as new load arrives, prices will keep doing the rationing, and voters will keep paying for it.

What this means for developers and operators

If you're on the development or operating side, Ohio is a preview of where site selection is heading.

A site's true cost now includes political and regulatory risk, not just the energy rate and the interconnection timeline. Before committing to a market, I'd want answers to a few questions:

  • Is there a large-load tariff in place or pending, and what minimum-take and collateral terms does it require?
  • How exposed is the site to PJM-style capacity prices, and how might those move over a 10- to 15-year contract?
  • Who pays for the transmission upgrades the project triggers, and how will that show up in public filings?
  • Is there an active local ballot measure or moratorium effort nearby?

Then run the full power cost and total cost of ownership, including your facility's PUE and a scenario where you're asked to cover more of the grid upgrades yourself. The projects that pencil out under those assumptions are the ones that will still be standing when the politics catch up.

The bottom line

Ohio's data center backlash is real, but it's aimed at what people can see. The costs that matter most travel through a regional grid, show up on bills years later, and depend on regulators most voters never think about.

Whoever wins in November, the decisions that set Ohio's power bills will be made at PUCO, at the statehouse, and inside PJM's markets, not just at the county zoning board. Every state with a data center pipeline should be watching, because Ohio's story is coming to their ballot next.

Chris Kalowes

Founder, WattThe?!

Energy intelligence. Simplified.

Frequently asked questions

Why are Ohio electricity bills going up so fast?+

Several costs are stacking up at once. Ohio sits inside PJM, the regional grid and wholesale market, where capacity auctions have cleared at record prices as forecasts for data center demand surged. Ohio utilities have also passed billions of dollars of new transmission spending through to customers. Because bills reflect regulatory decisions and fuel costs from earlier years, increases tend to show up well after the decisions that caused them.

Can a data center in another state raise my electric bill?+

Yes. In a regional market like PJM, capacity and transmission costs are shared across the footprint, so demand growth in one state can raise costs for customers in others. That is one reason local zoning votes do not fully control what households pay.

Who sets electricity rates in Ohio?+

The Public Utilities Commission of Ohio (PUCO) regulates utility rates and terms, while much of the generation and capacity cost is shaped by the PJM wholesale market. Ohio's governor appoints the five PUCO commissioners.

What is Ohio already doing to make data centers pay their own way?+

In July 2025, PUCO approved an AEP Ohio tariff requiring new data centers above 25 MW to pay for at least 85% of their contracted capacity for up to 12 years, with exit fees if projects are canceled. The same year, House Bill 15 ended ratepayer subsidies for two OVEC coal plants and tightened utility rate-case requirements.

What is a capacity auction?+

A capacity auction is how PJM pays power plants and other resources to be available during peak demand years in advance. When forecast demand rises faster than new supply, auction prices rise, and those costs flow into retail electric bills.