Back to Natural Gas & Behind-the-Meter Power
Natural Gas & Behind-the-Meter Power tools

Gas Turbine vs. Reciprocating Engine Sizing Calculator

Behind-the-meter gas plants come in two flavors: large gas turbines and banks of smaller reciprocating engines. Compare them head-to-head on N+1 unit count, installed capacity, capital cost, operating heat rate, fuel cost per MWh, and annual fuel cost — with the capex and fuel differences called out.

One spare unit beyond what the load needs (N+1) keeps load served if one fails.

Use delivered price (Henry Hub plus basis and transport).

Heat-rate increase at part load; turbines penalize part load more than engines.

Defaults are illustrative; use vendor quotes.

Turbine fuel cost
$40.28/MWh

operating heat rate × gas price

Engine fuel cost
$33.86/MWh

operating heat rate × gas price

Capex difference (engine − turbine)
$-70,800,000

negative = engines cheaper

Annual fuel difference (engine − turbine)
$-5,058,374

negative = engines burn less

Gas turbine vs. reciprocating engine

engines − turbines
MetricGas turbineRecip. engine
Total units37
Installed capacity150MW126MW
Installed cost$285,000,000$214,200,000
Operating heat rate10,070Btu/kWh8,466Btu/kWh
Fuel cost$40.28/MWh$33.86/MWh
Annual fuel cost$31,756,752$26,698,378
Capex difference (engine − turbine)$-70,800,000
Annual fuel difference (engine − turbine)$-5,058,374

Results update live as you type. For planning and field-check estimates — always verify against applicable standards and equipment ratings.

How we calculate this →
Insight

Many behind-the-meter projects choose engines because small units make N+1 redundancy cheaper and part-load efficiency better: at 100 MW with one spare, the engine fleet needs 126 MW installed versus 150 MW for turbines, and burns about $5 million less fuel per year at $4 gas. Turbines win on footprint and, at larger scale, on unit count. For fuel cost per MWh, see the Heat Rate & Fuel Cost per MWh Calculator; for full project economics, see the Behind-the-Meter Gas Plant LCOE Calculator.

How turbines and engines are sized against a load

A behind-the-meter gas plant has to serve a firm load, so it is built with redundancy: enough units to cover the load plus one spare (N+1) so a single failure does not drop load. Units for load = ROUNDUP(required load ÷ unit size) — round up because a partial unit cannot be built — and total units adds the spare. Installed capacity = total units × unit size, which is why smaller units size closer to the load: at 100 MW, two 50 MW turbines plus a spare give 150 MW installed, while six 18 MW engines plus a spare give 126 MW.

Capital cost scales installed capacity: installed cost ($) = installed capacity (MW) × 1,000 × installed cost ($/kW). Engines cost less per kW but need more units, so the comparison is not obvious — at the defaults the engine fleet is about $71 million cheaper to build. Heat rate sets fuel cost: operating heat rate = base heat rate × (1 + part-load penalty ÷ 100), and fuel cost ($/MWh) = operating heat rate ÷ 1,000 × gas price. Turbines penalize part load more than engines, so at the same gas price the engine fleet burns about $5 million less fuel per year.

The differences (engines minus turbines) make the trade-off explicit: a negative capex difference means engines cost less to build, and a negative annual fuel difference means engines burn less. Turbines win on physical footprint and, at very large scale, on unit count and maintenance labor. This model excludes emissions controls, air permits, maintenance intervals, and startup characteristics — all of which can change the choice. Use vendor quotes for both technologies before committing.

Frequently asked questions

Why use engines instead of turbines?

Smaller units give flexible redundancy, quick starts and good part-load efficiency.

Why use turbines instead of engines?

Larger units, smaller footprint per MW and less maintenance labor at scale.

What does N+1 mean?

One spare unit beyond what the load needs, so one failure does not drop load.

Does this include emissions controls?

No. Air permits can change cost and unit choice.